Employees sometimes take on additional responsibilities to cover staff absences, support busy departments or help with temporary projects. What begins as a short-term arrangement can eventually become a permanent part of their job.
When this happens, employers should review whether the employee’s Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) screening requirements remain appropriate. Changes in responsibilities, working arrangements and contact with children or adults may affect whether a role qualifies for a Basic, Standard or Enhanced DBS check.
Understanding when to reassess eligibility helps organisations maintain appropriate safeguarding arrangements without requesting checks that are not legally permitted.
Why Permanent Changes to Duties Matter
DBS eligibility is determined by the actual responsibilities and activities involved in a position, rather than its job title alone.
For example, an employee originally recruited for an administrative role might temporarily assist with duties involving direct contact with children or adults receiving care. If those responsibilities become a permanent part of the position, the employer should review the role’s eligibility.
Changes worth considering include:
- Taking on regular responsibilities involving children or adults.
- Providing healthcare, personal care or other relevant support.
- Moving into a position involving greater safeguarding responsibility.
- Taking on duties that may fall within regulated activity.
- Becoming responsible for managing or supervising certain activities.
A temporary arrangement should not automatically trigger a higher-level DBS application. However, when responsibilities change, employers should establish whether the revised role meets the relevant legal eligibility criteria.
When Should Employers Reassess DBS Eligibility?
Employers should review DBS eligibility whenever there is a significant change to an employee’s duties or working arrangements.
This does not mean every additional responsibility requires a new check. Instead, HR teams should consider whether the changes affect the legal basis for the existing level of screening.
For example, an employee who occasionally supports a different department may have different screening requirements from someone who permanently takes on duties involving regulated activity.
The review should consider:
- The activities the employee will actually perform.
- The people they will work with.
- The location and nature of the work.
- How frequently the activities will take place.
- Whether the responsibilities meet the legal definition of regulated activity.
Employers should use the latest DBS eligibility guidance when making this assessment.
Could a Change in Duties Require a Higher Level of DBS Check?
In some circumstances, yes. A permanent change in responsibilities may mean that an employee becomes eligible for a different level of DBS check.
The available levels include:
Basic DBS check: Shows unspent convictions and conditional cautions. It is available to anyone and does not require a specific role eligibility assessment.
Standard DBS check: Shows relevant spent and unspent convictions and cautions, subject to filtering rules. It is only available for positions listed in the relevant legislation.
Enhanced DBS check: Includes the information available through a Standard check, together with relevant information held by local police. The role must meet the specific eligibility requirements.
Enhanced DBS check with barred list information: May be available where the employee’s duties meet the legal definition of regulated activity with children, adults or both.
Employers must not automatically request an Enhanced or barred list check simply because an employee has received additional responsibilities. The revised duties must meet the relevant legal criteria.
What If an Employee Already Has a DBS Certificate?
A new application is not always necessary when an employee’s responsibilities change.
Employers should first review the existing certificate, including its level, workforce and suitability for the revised position.
If the employee is subscribed to the DBS Update Service, an eligible certificate may be checked online with the employee’s permission. However, the employer must ensure that the certificate meets the requirements for the new role and that the relevant Update Service conditions are satisfied.
If the existing certificate is not suitable for the revised responsibilities, a new application may be appropriate, provided the position is legally eligible for that level of check.
How HR Teams Can Manage Changes to Employee Duties
A consistent process helps organisations identify screening changes before temporary arrangements become permanent.
HR teams should:
- Review job descriptions: Keep records of the employee’s original and revised responsibilities.
- Assess eligibility: Compare the new duties with current DBS eligibility guidance.
- Consult relevant managers: Confirm how frequently the additional activities will take place and who the employee will work with.
- Review existing certificates: Check whether the current DBS certificate remains suitable.
- Explain any new requirements: Tell employees why additional screening may be necessary.
- Update HR records: Document the eligibility assessment and any decisions made.
Employers should also review safeguarding arrangements while any necessary application is being processed.
For further guidance, read our article on DBS checks when job duties expand during employment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a permanent change in job duties automatically require a new DBS check?
No. Employers should reassess eligibility, but a new application is only appropriate if the revised role meets the legal requirements for the relevant level of check and the existing certificate is insufficient.
Can an employee’s temporary duties affect DBS eligibility?
Potentially. The actual activities performed can affect eligibility, even when they are not reflected in the original job title. Employers should assess the relevant legal criteria rather than relying on whether the arrangement is described as temporary or permanent.
Can an employer request an Enhanced DBS check because an employee has more responsibilities?
Not automatically. Enhanced checks are restricted to legally eligible roles. Additional responsibilities must meet the relevant criteria before an employer can request this level of screening.
How often should employers review DBS eligibility?
Employers should review eligibility whenever significant changes occur to job responsibilities, working arrangements or the activities performed. Periodic reviews of job descriptions and safeguarding procedures can also help identify changes that may have been overlooked.
Conclusion
When temporary duties become permanent, employers should reassess whether the employee’s DBS screening remains appropriate. The key consideration is whether the revised responsibilities meet the legal eligibility requirements for a particular level of check.
By reviewing job descriptions, consulting current DBS guidance and maintaining accurate HR records, organisations can manage changes responsibly while supporting effective safeguarding and compliant recruitment practices.
